Last weekend, Saturday Night Live performed an awful skit, purportedly set in New York’s Central Park, depicting a supposed horse-carriage driver talking to potential customers. “Can you believe they passed a ban on horse-drawn carriages in New York City?” he asks rhetorically. “And for no reason at all except animal cruelty and human murders.” The skit is the definition of punching down at vulnerable people.
But don’t (entirely) blame SNL. The New York City Council, led by a supposedly moderate Democrat, Council Speaker Julie Menin, has invited this open season of gratuitous public shame on the horse-carriage industry’s 200 or so hardworking middle-class workers by falsely branding the business as abusive and dangerous.
Finally, a reason to check your email.
Sign up for our free newsletter today.
Contrary to the SNL writers’ charge, horse-carriage drivers aren’t “murderous.” There is no charge whatsoever that anyone has ever been murdered in this business. What the writers are referring to (disrespectfully) is the singular tragic death, in June, of 18-year-old passenger Romanch Mahajan, killed when the carriage in which he was riding overturned after the horse bolted. In a city full of preventable-injury deaths of all causes, though, Mahajan’s death is a rare example of an actual freak accident: it appears that the horse pulling his carriage was shocked by stray underground voltage in Central Park. To the extent that anyone is to blame, it’s a failure by New York City’s elected government, including Menin, as well as the nonprofit Central Park Conservancy, which manages the park, to conduct basic infrastructure maintenance.
There is not a sliver of credible evidence that horse-carriage drivers are cruel. The horses’ spacious stables are regulated, and the horses enjoy ample vacation time as well as breaks in extreme weather. In 2023, Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg prosecuted a driver for animal cruelty after his horse, suffering from a rare and hard-to-detect cancer, collapsed in the street and later died. A Manhattan jury, after hearing all the evidence, acquitted the man last year.
Why, then, would SNL broadcast these defamatory charges—especially just days after an unhinged, out-of-state young woman allegedly violently attacked a horse carriage driver, screaming charges of “abuse” and slamming the driver in the face with a skateboard? (The driver remained remarkably patient during and after suffering this alleged felony assault, but that’s no surprise: drivers have remained patient for years as ignorant activists have verbally and physically attacked them for nonexistent infractions.)
SNL is only taking its cues from New York’s lawmakers. In late October, Speaker Menin crowed over the fact that, after 19 years of trying, the council had finally passed a ban on the horse carriages. In doing so, Menin stood approvingly, in a TikTok style-video, as a representative from NYCLASS (New Yorkers for Clean, Livable, and Safer Streets) chirpily branded the industry “cruel and deadly.”
NYCLASS is a fact-free, unrepresentative special interest. It has one outsized supporter, a real-estate magnate, and 200 volunteers. It failed in bullying four previous city council speakers into passing a horse-carriage ban.
But finally, NYCLASS has found its target: a council speaker who appears to have jettisoned her principles to raise her public profile among boutique special interests, including the small but politically active animal-rights crowd. The fact that the city’s Campaign Finance Board once levied significant fines against NYCLASS for egregious campaign-finance violations related to this very issue didn’t appear to perturb Menin.
Menin isn’t alone. During the city council vote, Upper West Side council member Gale Brewer made a public joke of her vote to eliminate dozens of good-paying jobs. “Yeiggghhhh,” she proclaimed in recording her position on the council chambers floor, a riff on a horse’s “neigh.” Even if you support a horse-carriage ban, considering that it has caused dozens of families to worry about their livelihoods, why is this funny? After the cruel SNL skit, other elected officials piled on: Harvey Epstein, a downtown council member and ally of Mayor Zohran Mamdani, excerpted the show’s “human murders” slur on X. Manhattan’s borough president, Brad Hoylman-Sigal, similarly piled on to the mockery.
In passing the bill to ban this sturdy industry, Menin and the council haven’t just ignored the absence of any evidence supporting allegations of harm. Menin has also created an untenable situation for the horse-carriage drivers themselves. It’s bad enough that the ban offers no concrete provision to help drivers to find new jobs in a shrinking tourist industry: New York’s leisure and hospitality sector has lost 15,400 jobs since last September and remains 6 percent smaller than before the 2020 pandemic.
Nor does the ban offer any provision to compensate horse-carriage owners for having invested more than six figures each in the government-issued medallions required to operate, nor any financing to ensure that horses rendered valueless overnight go to good homes rather than to the slaughterhouse. Several horse-carriage drivers to whom I’ve spoken are distraught that they may not be able to afford to continue to care for their much-loved animals.
That’s all bad enough, but the Menin council has also sent a signal to the city, the nation, and the world, as evidenced in the SNL skit: these workers—now dealing with the knowledge that they are losing their jobs, their investment, and their slice of urban culture—are to be publicly vilified for fun.
The SNL skit made sport of the drivers’ demeanor and attire—the sin of being different. “You just trust me implicitly? You do realize I have a top hat and a whip, right?” SNL’s fake driver asks his fake customers.
Indeed, horse-carriage drivers are different; they’re unique in New York City. They don’t depend on government subsidies. They don’t work in offices, or from home, on laptops all day. They aren’t gig-delivery workers dependent on an algorithm to set their hours and pay. They work with—and control—large animals, when most urban dwellers and visitors are far removed from both nature and farming, and thus unfamiliar with what such work looks like.
It is hard, and growing harder, for New Yorkers to relate not just to horses but to the people who care for them. It’s a story as old as time, or as grade school, as SNL so viciously demonstrated: people who are different are easy prey for mob mockery.
Worse, though, the horse-carriage drivers are now targets of more potential violence beyond this week’s assault. The ban Menin pushed through the council, assuming it survives court challenges, won’t take effect until June 2028, nearly two years from now. In the meantime, these horse-carriage drivers must ply their trade in the public park, with no protection against animal-rights terrorists, vigilantes, and other deranged individuals. Already, the drivers face heightened workplace violence, as shown by last week’s attack. Now, a major network’s TV and streaming show, encouraged by Menin’s council and egged on by two other elected officials, has just falsely smeared the drivers as abusers and murderers.
Many moderate and conservative New Yorkers understandably think that Mayor Mamdani is the city’s main anti-business and anti-investor force. Yet Mamdani has yet to sign the bill banning horse carriages. (He has said that he will sign it but has inexplicably delayed doing so for weeks).
If even Mamdani, with his government-run grocery stores and sustained attack on small landlords, pauses over the demonization and ostracization of a small business, that should tell you something.